Benchmarks

The odbc package is often much faster than the existing RODBC and DBI compatible RODBCDBI packages. We’ll benchmark writing and reading data from the nycflights13 package using the three packages.

Setup

RODBC and RODBCDBI trip up on flights’ tibble subclass, so we’ll convert it to a data frame before passing to each package. Also, the RODBCDBI package does not support writing timestamps, so we remove that column as well.

flights$time_hour <- NULL
flights <- as.data.frame(flights)

Now, let’s configure three driver connections to a Microsoft SQL Server database, one for each package we’ll be benchmarking.

odbc <- dbConnect(odbc::odbc(), dsn = "MicrosoftSQLServer", uid = "SA", pwd = "BoopBop123!")
rodbc <- RODBC::odbcConnect(dsn = "MicrosoftSQLServer", uid = "SA", pwd = "BoopBop123!")
rodbcdbi <- dbConnect(RODBCDBI::ODBC(), dsn = "MicrosoftSQLServer", user = "SA", password = "BoopBop123!")

The above code requires a dsn MicrosoftSQLServer to have been previously configured; see vignettes("setup") to learn more.

Writing

We’ll first benchmark writing the flights dataset, which contains ~300,000 rows and 18 columns, to a database.

The code for odbc and RODBCDBI looks quite similar, as they both use the DBI front-end:

odbc_write <- system.time(dbWriteTable(odbc, "flights", flights))

odbc_write

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  0.883   0.176   8.108

rodbcdbi_write <- system.time(dbWriteTable(rodbcdbi, "flights", flights))

rodbcdbi_write

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  8.287  11.107 257.841

The timings for RODBC and RODBCDBI are quite similar, as they both utilize the RODBC back-end:

rodbc_write <- system.time(sqlSave(rodbc, flights, "flights"))

rodbc_write

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  8.266  11.023 235.825

Reading

Again, the syntax for odbc and RODBCDBI is identical, while the timings for RODBCDBI and RODBC are quite similar.

odbc_read     <- system.time(result <- dbReadTable(odbc, "flights"))
rodbcdbi_read <- system.time(result <- dbReadTable(rodbcdbi, "flights"))
rodbc_read    <- system.time(result <- sqlFetch(rodbc, "flights"))

odbc_read

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  0.515   0.024   0.557

rodbcdbi_read

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  1.308   0.035   1.356

rodbc_read

#>   user  system elapsed 
#>  1.291   0.033   1.343