gnomonicM: An R Package to Estimate Natural Mortality for different life stages

Install package
1. Natural mortality (M) via deterministic method
- Print and plot for deterministic method
2. Natural mortality (M) via stochastic method: the Pacific chub mackerel (Scomber japonicus) case
- Print and plot for stochastic method
3. Different distributions in MLF
4. Testing in other species
5. References

This vignette introduces you to gnomonicM package and provides a way to estimate Natural Mortality (M) throughout the life history of species, mainly fish and invertebrates.

Install package

You can install from CRAN:

install.packages("gnomonicM")

Or the development version from github:

# install.packages("devtools")
devtools::install_github("ejosymart/gnomonicM")

After that, call the package:

library("gnomonicM")

1. Natural mortality (M) via deterministic method

For estimating M we will use the data provided by Caddy (1996) based on two species with: (i) seven gnomonic intervals, (ii) egg stage duration of 2 days, (iii) a longevity of one year (365 days), (iv) a mean lifetime fecundity (MLF) of 200000 (high fecundity, hf) and 135 eggs (low fecundity, lf), and (v) initial constant proportionality (\(\alpha\)) value of 2.

model_hf <- gnomonic(nInterval   = 7, 
                     eggDuration = 2, 
                     longevity   = 365, 
                     fecundity   = 200000, 
                     a_init      = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## --------------------------------------------------------

model_lf <- gnomonic(nInterval   = 7, 
                     eggDuration = 2, 
                     longevity   = 365, 
                     fecundity   = 135, 
                     a_init      = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## --------------------------------------------------------

If you have additional information related to the duration of the other gnomonic intervals, you could provide them via the argument addInfo. For example, if we assume that the duration of the second and fifth gnomonic interval is equal to 4 and 40 days respectively, we will have to include this information as follows:

modelAddInfo <- gnomonic(nInterval   = 7, 
                         eggDuration = 2, 
                         addInfo     = c(4, NA, NA, 40, NA, NA),
                         longevity   = 365, 
                         fecundity   = 200000, 
                         a_init      = 2)

The NA values in the argument addInfo must be written to complete the length of the vector. In this case the length of the addInfo vector is equal to nInterval - 1.

Print and plot for deterministic method

Print the results of the model_hf or model_lf. The output is an object of class gnomos. This object contains a list with the constant proportionality value (\(\alpha\)), the constant proportion of the overall natural death rate (G), a dataframe with the duration (“interval_duration_day”), and the natural mortality (“M_day” and “M_year”) for each gnomonic interval.

For plotting, an object of class gnomos is required. The function plot generates a scatter plot with the values of M for each gnomonic interval. You can modify the labels via xlab, ylab, the color via bg and the sizes of points in the scatter plot, also you can pass arguments to the plot method.

#Species with high fecundity.
print(model_hf)

## Proportionality constant (alpha) = 1.381646 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## Constant proportion of the overall natural death rate (G) = 1.644704 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## Main results of gnomonic method: 
## 
##   Gnomonic_interval interval_duration_day total_duration M_day  M_year No_Surv
## 1                 1                 2.000              2 0.822 300.158   38614
## 2                 2                 2.763              5 0.595 217.247    7455
## 3                 3                 6.581             11 0.250  91.217    1439
## 4                 4                15.674             27 0.105  38.300     278
## 5                 5                37.330             64 0.044  16.081      54
## 6                 6                88.907            153 0.018   6.752      10
## 7                 7               211.745            365 0.008   2.835       2

plot(model_hf)

#Species with low fecundity.
print(model_lf)

## Proportionality constant (alpha) = 1.381646 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## Constant proportion of the overall natural death rate (G) = 0.6017325 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## Main results of gnomonic method: 
## 
##   Gnomonic_interval interval_duration_day total_duration M_day  M_year No_Surv
## 1                 1                 2.000              2 0.301 109.816      74
## 2                 2                 2.763              5 0.218  79.482      41
## 3                 3                 6.581             11 0.091  33.373      22
## 4                 4                15.674             27 0.038  14.012      12
## 5                 5                37.330             64 0.016   5.884       7
## 6                 6                88.907            153 0.007   2.470       4
## 7                 7               211.745            365 0.003   1.037       2

plot(model_lf, xlab = "My X label", ylab = "My Y label", cex = 3, bg = "blue")

For comparative purposes, we present the results provided by Caddy (1996). Note: We have multiplied the interval duration by 365 in order to have day units.

Results provided by Caddy (1996) in the estimation of M based on high fecundity species (MLF = 200,000 eggs, egg stage duration = 2 days, and longevity = 365 days)
Gnomonic_interval	interval_duration_day	M_year	No_Surv
1	2.00	300.16	38614
2	2.76	217.25	7455
3	6.58	91.27	1439
4	15.67	38.30	278
5	37.33	16.08	54
6	88.91	6.75	10
7	211.75	2.84	2

Results provided by Caddy (1996) in the estimation of M based on low fecundity species (MLF = 135, egg stage duration = 2 days, and longevity = 365 days)
Gnomonic_interval	interval_duration_day	M_year	No_Surv
1	2.00	109.82	74
2	2.76	79.48	41
3	6.58	33.37	22
4	15.67	14.01	12
5	37.33	5.88	7
6	88.91	2.47	4
7	211.75	1.04	2

2. Natural mortality (M) via stochastic method: the Pacific chub mackerel (Scomber japonicus) case

The function to be used to estimate M is gnomonicStochastic. The previous estimation of natural mortality, which was based on the gnomonic function, did not include any measures of deviation. In this method we calculated these measures assuming that the main source of uncertainty and variability was the mean lifetime fecundity (MLF).

We have included three different distribution function via the argument distr. It could be normal: distr = 'normal', uniform: distr = 'uniform', and triangular: distr = 'triangle'. Once you have chosen a particular distribution function, you must to include information related with the minimum, maximum, mean and standard deviation (sd) of MLF.

We will use the information reported by the chub mackerel, based on an (i) eight gnomonic intervals, (ii) egg stage duration of 2.33 days (56 hours), (iii) a longevity of eight years (2920 days), (iv) a mean lifetime fecundity (MLF) of 78174 [11805 - 144543] and 28978 [7603 - 53921] eggs assuming uniform distribution, and (v) initial constant proportionality (\(\alpha\)) value of 2. We simulated 1000 estimates of natural mortality for each gnomonic intervals and estimated mean mortality rate (\(\bar{M_i}\)), the confidence interval, and the standard deviation (\(\sigma_{i}\)).

model_cm_hf <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 8, 
                                  eggDuration   = 2.33,
                                  longevity     = 2920,
                                  distr         = "uniform", 
                                  min_fecundity = 11805, 
                                  max_fecundity = 144543, 
                                  niter         = 1000, 
                                  a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2.33 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

model_cm_lf <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 8, 
                                  eggDuration   = 2.33,
                                  longevity     = 2920,
                                  distr         = "uniform", 
                                  min_fecundity = 7603, 
                                  max_fecundity = 53921, 
                                  niter         = 1000, 
                                  a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2.33 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

Print and plot for stochastic method

Printing and plotting the result of the stochastic method follow the same idea that deterministic method. In this case when using print it includes the niter values of G and fecundity, and the M values for each gnomonic intervals for each iteration. The plot is based on a boxplot and the arguments could be modified as in the deterministic method.

#The results are not shown here. Please run it in your console.
print(model_cm_hf)

print(model_cm_lf)

In the previous plots, by default, the M values have \(day^{-1}\) units (dayUnits = TRUE). You can modify it via the argument dayUnits = FALSE which will show a plot with the M values in \(year^{-1}\) units.

par(mar = c(6,6,6,6))
plot(model_cm_hf, main = "M for chub mackerel, MLF = [11 805 - 144 543]", dayUnits = FALSE)

plot(model_cm_lf, main = "M for chub mackerel, MLF = [7 603 - 53 921]", dayUnits = FALSE)

3. Different distributions in MLF

In this section, we test different distribution functions in the MLF via the argument distr. There are three options: distr = 'normal', distr = 'uniform' and distr = 'triangle'. You must include particular information related to the minimum, maximum, mean, and standard deviation (sd) of MLF based on the particular distribution function.

modelUniformAddInfo <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 7, 
                                          eggDuration   = 2,
                                          addInfo       = c(4, NA, NA, 40, NA, NA),
                                          longevity     = 365,
                                          distr         = "uniform", 
                                          min_fecundity = 100000, 
                                          max_fecundity = 300000, 
                                          niter         = 1000, 
                                          a_init        = 2)

## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

modelNormal <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 7, 
                                  eggDuration   = 2,
                                  longevity     = 365,
                                  distr         = "normal", 
                                  fecundity     = 200000, 
                                  sd_fecundity  = 50000, 
                                  niter         = 1000, 
                                  a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'normal distribution' for fecundity."

modelTriangle <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 7, 
                                    eggDuration   = 2,
                                    longevity     = 365,
                                    distr         = "triangle", 
                                    fecundity     = 200000,
                                    min_fecundity = 100000,
                                    max_fecundity = 300000,
                                    niter         = 1000, 
                                    a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'triangular distribution' for fecundity."

plot(modelUniformAddInfo, main = "Uniform distribution in MLF, with additional information")

plot(modelNormal, main = "Normal distribution in MLF")

plot(modelTriangle, main = "Triangular distribution in MLF")

4. Testing in other species

This section shows the applications to published data that used the gnomonic model (see, Ramírez-Rodríguez & Arreguín-Sánchez (2003); Martínez-Aguilar et al (2005); Giménez-Hurtado et al. (2009); Martínez-Aguilar et al. (2010); Aranceta-Garza et al. (2016); Romero-Gallardo et al. (2018)). It gave the chance to assess the approach in different taxa (fish, invertebrates) and life-history (demersal, pelagic, benthic, short, and large life span).

Farfantopenaeus <-  gnomonic(nInterval   = 7,
                             eggDuration = 1.5, 
                             longevity   = 480,
                             fecundity   = 500000,
                             a_init      = 1)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 1.5 
## 
## --------------------------------------------------------

Vannamei <- gnomonic(nInterval   = 7,
                     eggDuration = 0.54, 
                     longevity   = 365,
                     fecundity   = 265000,   
                     a_init      = 3)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 0.54 
## 
## --------------------------------------------------------

Sardinops <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 10,
                                eggDuration   = 2.5, 
                                longevity     = 2555,
                                min_fecundity = 646763,
                                max_fecundity = 1090678,
                                niter         = 1000, 
                                a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2.5 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

Epinephelus <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 11,
                                  eggDuration   = 2, 
                                  longevity     = 7300,
                                  min_fecundity = 102000,
                                  max_fecundity = 573500,
                                  niter         = 1000, 
                                  a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

Dosidicus <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 5,
                                eggDuration   = 6, 
                                longevity     = 438,
                                min_fecundity = 813000,
                                max_fecundity = 25887000,
                                niter         = 1000, 
                                a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 6 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

Isostichopus <- gnomonicStochastic(nInterval     = 6,
                                   eggDuration   = 2,
                                   longevity     = 3650,
                                   min_fecundity = 13500,
                                   max_fecundity = 5062490, 
                                   niter         = 1000,
                                   a_init        = 2)

## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## No additional information. You are only considering the egg stage duration = 2 
## 
## -------------------------------------------------------- 
## 
## [1] "You are using a 'uniform distribution' for fecundity."

par(mar=c(5.1, 4.1, 6, 2.1))
plot(Farfantopenaeus, main = "M for Farfantopenaeus duorarum", dayUnits = FALSE)

plot(Vannamei, main = "M for Penaeus vannamei", col = "darkred", dayUnits = FALSE)

plot(Sardinops, main = "M for Sardinops caeruleus", col = "blue")

plot(Epinephelus, main = "M for Epinephelus morio", col = "darkgreen", dayUnits = FALSE)

plot(Dosidicus, main = "M for Dodisicus gigas", col = "purple", dayUnits = FALSE)

plot(Isostichopus, main = "M for Isostichopus badionotus", col = "skyblue", dayUnits = FALSE)

5. References

Aranceta-Garza F, Arreguín-Sánchez F, Ponce-Díaz G, Seijo JC. 2016. Natural mortality of three commercial penaeid shrimps (Litopenaeus vannamei, L. stylirostris and Farfantepenaeus californiensis) of the Gulf of California using gnomonic time divisions. Scientia Marina 80:199–206.

Caddy JF. 1991. Death rates and time intervals: is there an alternative to the constant natural mortality axiom? Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 1:109–138. doi:10.1007/BF00157581.

Caddy JF. 1996. Modelling natural mortality with age in short-lived invertebrate populations: definition of a strategy of gnomonic time division. Aquatic Living Resources 9:197–207.

Giménez-Hurtado E, Arreguín-Sánchez F, Lluch-Cota SE. 2009. Natural Mortality Rates during Life History Stages of the Red Grouper on Campeche Bank, Mexico. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 29:216–222.

Martínez-Aguilar S, Arreguín-Sánchez F, Morales-Bojórquez E. 2005. Natural mortality and life history stage duration of Pacific sardine (Sardinops caeruleus) based on gnomonic time divisions. Fisheries Research 71:103–114.

Martínez-Aguilar S, Díaz Uribe JG, De Anda-Montañez JA, Cisneros-Mata MA. 2010. Natural mortality and life history stage duration for the jumbo squid (Dosidicus gigas) in the Gulf of California, Mexico, using the gnomonic time division. Ciencia Pesquera 18:31–42.

Ramírez-Rodríguez M, Arreguín-Sánchez F. 2003. Life history stage duration and natural mortality for the pink shrimp Farfantepenaeus duorarum (Burkenroad, 1939) in the southern Gulf of Mexico, using the gnomonic model for time division. Fisheries Research 60:45–51.

Romero-Gallardo S, Velazquez-Abunader I, Alberto Lopez-Rocha J, Garza-Gisholt E. 2018. Natural mortality estimates throughout the life history of the sea cucumber Isostichopus badionotus (Holothuroidea: Aspidochirotida). PeerJ 6:e5235.